Edward A. Lee, Professor of the Graduate School and Robert S. Pepper Distinguished Professor Emeritus in Electrical Engineering and Computer Science at UC Berkeley. Professor Lee's research group studies cyber-physical systems, which integrate physical dynamics with software and networks. He focuses on the use of deterministic models as a central part of the engineering toolkit for such systems. He has led the development of several influential open-source software packages, notably Lingua Franca and Ptolemy.
Author of books: "The Coevolution: The Entwined Futures of Humans and Machines" (2020), "Plato and the Nerd: The Creative Partnership of Humans and Technology" (2017), "Introduction to Embedded Systems: A Cyber-Physical Systems Approach" (2017).
Should we give different definitions to contemporary art produced by humans and by machines? Is the stress on contemporary important for you?
One possible interpretation is that machines, no matter how sophisticated, are a medium for art creation rather than a creator of art. A paintbrush is a simple machine. An AI is a more complicated machine. I make this point chapter 10 of The Coevolution, where I also compare computer-generated art to Duchamp's found objects and to conceptual art. The Portrait of Edmond de Belamy, for example, can be interpreted as a piece of conceptual art, where the concept is that of the world's first AI-generated artwork, but under this interpretation, the AI is not the artist. The three French guys who call themselves OBVIOUS are.
As for the importance of "contemporary," to me, this just means "recently created." I don't see it as a style.
Is art necessarily connected with the notion of creativity? If yes, please provide a definition of creativity. If not, then what is the “engine” of art (e. g. you consider art as a spiritual practice or a natural part of life and industrial production as Soviet productivists did etc.)?
Creativity is inextricably tied to novelty, and I feel that novelty is overrated. New is not better than good. That said, art is more effective when it has an element of surprise. This element, however, is fundamentally not durable, so it does not explain how an artwork can continue to be good even though you have seen it a thousand times hanging on your living room wall. I think the Soviet productivists were aligned with other art movements of the time, although I'm no expert in art history. Mass production and integration of art with everyday life, I believe, were broad concepts in the 20th century. I own a magazine cover that is an original Rauschenberg lithograph, printed some 200,000 times and sent to all subscribers to a magazine called Tropic.
Do you see any medium limitations in machine-produced art? In perceiving machine produced art?
I think that images and sound are easily handled with today's technology. Additive manufacturing and computer-controlled lathes and the like are still largely within the realm of conventional media, where the level of human involvement is still large enough that it's hard to see anything they produce as machine-produced art. This could change, but I don't think this will happen anytime soon. The reason for this belief is that to be perceived by humans as art, there needs to be a selection phase, where one or more humans select from among a variety of machine-produced outputs. Generating many physical objects from additive manufacturing and selecting from among them doesn't appeal as much as generating many images and selecting from among them.
How do you see machine artists’ ethic code if both — humans and machines — could contribute to it? Do you imagine machine artists’ impact on human artists’ in a way like an authorship vs cc, high res vs circulationism etc.)?
Chapters 10-12 of my book, The Coevolution, are all about this. They address the question of attribution (how to assign credit or blame) and how and whether machines can be held accountable for their actions. I argue that machines already have some of the basic attributes required for accountability (specifically, the ability to reason about causality), but this is very primitive in today's machines. Moreover, I argue if the machines ever acquire some true agency in the sense we know it as humans, we will never be able to be sure that they actually have that.
A perhaps more interesting question is whether machine art will always be created for human consumption, or whether machine art for machine consumption will emerge. I would argue, in fact, that until machine art is created for machine consumption, machines remain a medium for human art.
Find more information about Edward A. Lee